25. Promises, promises: The Ethics of Unbridled Optimism

No votes yet

Science journalists insist on promising their audiences a better world. Reading through a few issues of any science magazine gives one the impression that all the problems in the world are now (or will soon be) solved with the help of science. But do science journalists really give accurate and trustworthy reports from the fields of science and technology, or do they give ungrounded promises? And, are these promises biased by economical, national, political, or religious motives? This session will address this issue from four points of view-- historic, geographic, economic, and cultural. The aim is to show how science journalism's often unbridled optimism, even if well-intended, may actually benefit ideological, religious, or chauvinistic interests more it does than the public—and to suggest ways journalists can avoid falling into these "promise-traps".

AttachmentSize
25_George Claassen.pdf1015.59 KB
25_Wolfgang c Geode.pdf2.09 MB
Place & time
Venue detail: 
Donald English Room
Date & Time: 
Thursday, July 2, 2009 - 11:30 - 13:00
People
Producer: 
Multimedia files
Audio clip: 

You are missing some Flash content that should appear here! Perhaps your browser cannot display it, or maybe it did not initialize correctly.

Session reviews: 
2009-07-14 04:39

Kaianders Sempler, editor of Ny Teknik, in his famous flower straw hat almost acted his introductory piece. He began from the Greek Euripides, who in his play brought first discussion tyranny vs. democracy, advantages and disadvantages of each. Discussion served as a system of solving problems by considering all possibilities without having to go to war. Politicians in democracy give promises which they forget once they are elected. Tyrants can concentrate on huge goals – but these can serve their own agenda.

2009-07-03 13:26

A strong historical flavour permeated this session, which nevertheless dealt with problems that face every modern science journalist who wants to produce high-class, ethical work.

Website design and conference organisation by Benchmark

Photographs copyright:

  • 5th World Conference of Science Journalists, Melbourne Australia
  • ScienceinPublic
  • Visit London
  • World Federation of Science Journalists

WCSJ 2009
Benchmark Communications
14 Blandford Square
Newcastle upon Tyne
NE1 4HZ

Email: info@wcsj2009.org
Tel: +44 (0)191 241 4523